Research in 2023 from Gallup, Pew Research Center, and SHRM suggests that great bosses do something far less glamorous than lead inspirational TED Talks or drip with charisma: actually, they treat people well.
Employees want respect, fairness, clear expectations, trust, recognition, and a little empathy. They want a boss who doesn’t lose their mind when things go wrong, who gives credit where it’s due, and who understands that employees occasionally have lives that don’t revolve around quarterly goals.
But being a good boss isn’t just about being nice. Great managers also set high standards, make difficult decisions, give honest feedback, and hold people accountable. Sometimes the kindest thing a boss can do is have an uncomfortable conversation rather than avoid it.
Researchers identify several varieties of destructive leadership. There’s the results-at-any-cost boss, who delivers impressive numbers while leaving emotional wreckage behind. The wrecking-ball boss, who manages to damage both employees and the organization. The friendly rule-breaker, who protects favorite employees while ignoring the rules. And the absent boss, whose refusal to make decisions leaves everyone else fighting fires.
The consequences are serious. In a 2023 American Psychological Association survey, 19% of workers described their workplace as toxic. Among those workers, 52% reported that their work environment harmed their mental health.
Crina and Kirsten explore how to recognize toxic leadership, why organizations tolerate it, and what employees can realistically do when their boss is the problem. Because “just quit” isn’t particularly helpful when you have a mortgage, health insurance, and children who insist on eating.
GOOD READS
Most American workers say their boss is capable, confident and fair.
APA poll reveals toxic workplaces, other significant workplace mental health challenges.